Nuclear Disarmament Cannot Be Another Diplomatic Photo Opportunity
As Trump, Xi, and Putin prepare to meet, real progress must mean verifiable reductions in nuclear weapons, accountability to affected communities, and a commitment to redirecting military resources toward human needs.
On November 19, President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Russian President Vladimir Putin are expected to meet in Shenzhen, China, for an unprecedented trilateral discussion that could help determine the future of nuclear arms control.
The meeting comes at a critical moment. The New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New START), the last major treaty limiting deployed U.S. and Russian strategic nuclear weapons, expired in February 2026. Without a replacement, the world’s two largest nuclear powers face a future without legally binding limits on their deployed strategic arsenals.
Diplomacy is urgently needed. But diplomatic engagement alone does not constitute progress toward peace.
At the Peace Economy Project, we believe the success of these talks must be measured not by photographs, declarations, or geopolitical prestige, but by concrete commitments to reduce the threat of nuclear war and redirect resources toward human security.
The economic consequences of nuclear competition
Nuclear weapons represent more than instruments of military deterrence. They also reflect political and economic choices about what governments value.
Every dollar allocated to expanding nuclear arsenals is a dollar unavailable for other public priorities. Nuclear modernization programs compete for resources with affordable housing, education, public health, climate resilience, and infrastructure.
These choices have consequences far beyond military installations and government budgets.
Communities struggling with poverty, environmental degradation, inadequate healthcare, and underfunded schools bear the opportunity costs of national spending priorities that consistently favor military power over human well-being.
Nuclear disarmament must therefore be understood not simply as an arms control objective but as an essential component of building a peace economy.
Disarmament cannot depend on perfect agreement
China has resisted participation in trilateral nuclear arms control negotiations, arguing that its arsenal remains substantially smaller than those of the United States and Russia.
That disparity matters. The United States and Russia retain a particular responsibility to pursue immediate, verifiable reductions because of the extraordinary scale of their nuclear stockpiles.
China’s participation in future agreements would be valuable, but it must not become an excuse for Washington and Moscow to postpone meaningful action.
The expiration of New START should accelerate negotiations, not normalize an era of unconstrained nuclear competition.
At a minimum, the three governments should pursue transparency measures, nuclear risk-reduction mechanisms, and a credible framework for negotiating enforceable limits.
Peace cannot be decided by three governments alone
The reported exclusion of Ukraine and Taiwan from the meeting’s principal discussions raises another critical concern: the concentration of global security decisions among a handful of powerful states.
The people most affected by war and militarization must have a voice in decisions concerning their security and future.
Nor should nuclear policy overlook communities harmed by weapons production, uranium extraction, and nuclear testing. Their experiences demonstrate that the human costs of nuclear militarization are not hypothetical. They are historical, environmental, economic, and intergenerational.
Meaningful security requires accountability to these communities, respect for national sovereignty, and participation beyond the world’s largest military powers.
A different measure of security
The Peace Economy Project calls upon the United States, China, and Russia to move beyond symbolic diplomacy and commit to measurable steps toward nuclear disarmament.
We urge the three governments to establish credible negotiating mechanisms, strengthen transparency and verification, reduce the risk of nuclear confrontation, and develop enforceable agreements that progressively reduce nuclear arsenals.
We also call upon the United States to confront the economic consequences of its nuclear weapons policies.
Resources freed through genuine disarmament should be redirected toward the needs of communities: healthcare, education, housing, environmental restoration, and the institutions that make human security possible.
The measure of national strength should not be how many times a nation can destroy the world. It should be how effectively that nation protects and sustains life.
If the meeting in Shenzhen produces only another declaration of great-power influence, it will be a missed opportunity.
If it establishes a pathway toward verifiable disarmament and a reordering of national priorities, it could represent an important step toward a more peaceful and equitable world.
Peace is not simply the absence of nuclear war. It is the presence of the conditions that allow people and communities to thrive.
That is the future the Peace Economy Project believes governments should be negotiating.


